A to Z and J is for Jack Who?

Let’s get this straight. I grew up with Jack and the Beanstalk. I’m not even sure where I heard the story. I think as a fairy tale in one of those little Golden Books they used to read to us. The story told of a boy named Jack who was sent to town to sell his mother’s cow and on the way came across someone with a hen that supposedly laid a golden egg. The boy was conned out of the cow for the hen and he took the chicken home and some how or another traded the hen for the beans…or something like that. Why am I confused? Well because history has confused the story.

You see, Jack and the Beanstalk has been confused with Jack the Giant Slayer and a host of other tales. The stories have been jumbled throughout history and not just by Hollywood or Disney.

The earliest recorded tale is Benjamin Tabart’s  The History of Jack and the Bean Stalk in 1807*. However, the story was circulating long before that one. The Brother’s Grimm mixed up Jack’s account of slaying giants with a story called The Devil with the Three Golden Hairs. The Fee Fie Fo Fum came from Shakespeare King Lear. The earliest version has Jack playing on the sympathy of the Giant’s wife, hangs out in the big guy’s house and then kills him. Totally not a nice thing to do, so Tabart had a fairy come and tell Jack that the giant killed his father, thus giving Jack a moral (somewhat) excuse to kill the giant. Later versions had Jack finding his hen in the Giant’s possession, and having the giant terrorize the people of Jack’s village. The 1952 film by Abbott and Costello blamed the giant for Jack’s poverty.


From The Project Gutenberg eBook, English Fairy Tales (1918), by Flora Annie Steel, Illustrated by Arthur Rackham

Now if you take this Jack, who supposedly planted some seeds that grew to an uncanny height (following the tradition of ancient European legend of a vine that could climb to heaven) and climbed the plant to a world in the sky, came across a land infiltrated by giants…well in Jack and the Beanstalk it was one giant. But then…there’s another Jack. Jack the Giant Slayer.

When I saw the 2013 movie I thought the story was a modern take off of the old Golden Book story. Goes to show…No. Jack the Giant Slayer is somebody different. This Jack wanders around the hillside of Wales during the reign of King Arthur and kills giants. Lots of them, and all in a bloody gory way. I don’t believe he’s related at all to the beanstalk guy unless they are distant cousins ‘twice removed’ or some such lot.

So…it appears our modern tale tellers have stirred these two public figures together and mixed the potion even more…because the 2013 movie has Jack climbing the vine and killing giants. Lots of them. And he has some of King Arthur’s men in pursuit to boot!

I like the way they introduce the trailer. “If you think you know the story…you don’t know Jack.” Yep! You’re right!



. Tasha’s Thinkings (Vampires) 7. Making Believe 13. Stacy Claflin (vampires and more)
2. Sophie’s Thoughts & Fumbles (Ghosts) 8. Write Accountable (Fairy Tales) 14. Amy Michele
3. The Other Side: The A to Z of Witches 9. Sara C. Snider (Mythical Creatures and People) 15. Multicolored Diary (myth & folklore of colors)
4. A Creative Mind 10. Mina Burrows (Classic Monsters) 16. Tracey Tobin
5. Anna @ Deeply Shallow (mythical creatures) 11. Julia Matthews Paranormal Adult Romance (Occult)
6. Moon, Light and Shadow 12. Precious Monsters

About Dianne Gardner

With a passion for wholesome and entertaining stories, Dianne Lynn Gardner dives into fantasy novels both adult and young adult. She is both a best selling author and an award winning illustrator who lives in the Pacific Northwest, USA. Mother of seven and grandmother of 16, Dianne wants to make sure that books which ignite imaginations, strengthen friendships, spur courage and applaud honor are available to every reader in the world.
This entry was posted in A to Z and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to A to Z and J is for Jack Who?

  1. Tarkabarka says:

    Actually, there are tons of Jack tales. While there is probably more than one Jack in folklore, there were also 23 different Herculeses, (Herculi?), and they are still told as the story of one person. Storytellers mostly just refer to Jack as one person. We do that a lot with tricksters. It’s like “oh, that’s a Jack story” or “oh, that’s an Anansi story.”
    Jack the Giant Slayer was not the best movie, though… 😀

    @TarkabarkaHolgy from
    Multicolored Diary – Tales of colors
    MopDog – The crazy thing about Hungarians…

  2. I’ve read Jack & The Beanstalk and Jack The Giant Slayer as two separate fairytales, but I don’t remember any reference to Wales in the Giant Slayer, although I just googled it to remind my self of the details, and the names of the giants ring some bells – it’s been a while since I read it. Hollywood has indeed mixed and matched with it’s new movie 🙂
    Sophie’s Thoughts & Fumbles – A to Z Ghosts
    Fantasy Boys XXX – A to Z Drabblerotic

  3. timsbrannan says:

    Wow. I never knew that! Thank you for sharing this.

    Timothy S. Brannan
    The Other Side, April Blog Challenge: The A to Z of Witches

  4. I seem to recall that Cinderella had a whole different life history, as well.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s